Movies, Documentary

The Times of Harvey Milk

15 August 2009

image This documentary about the life of Harvey Milk starts at the moment of his election to the city council of San Francisco. Compared the recent motion picture Milk, the film begins a bit slow but then becomes a wonderful depiction of what made Milk a great politician. It is quite remarkable to see him organize the gay community into a political force. All in all, the documentary is more gratifying than the motion picture because Milk playing Milk is a lot more convincing then Sean Penn playing Milk.  Towards the end, the director devotes considerable time trying to figure out what motivated Dan White to shoot the major of San Francisco and Harvey Milk. No good answers emerge from White’s biography. The film cannot uncover any evidence of psychological instability or sublimated aggression that periodically would have erupted. I suspect that if White hadn’t had a gun readily available at home the day of the crime, he would have calmed down

in a couple of days and not become a murderer. This seemingly all-American boy would have avoided jail and not committed suicide a few years later. I realize this may be too simple an account.  But only digging a lot deeper into the history of White than both films managed to do is going to provide more secure answer.

Author

Peter

This entry has been viewed 451 times.

Your Comments

0 Responses. Comments closed for this entry.


© 2024 Peter Murmann. Powered by ExpressionEngine.

Daily Edition Theme by WooThemes - Premium ExpressionEngine Themes